
How to Identify and Prevent Wine Faults in Your Craft Wine
RJS Craft Winemaking
Every winemaker’s end goal is to produce a wine that is squeaky clean and free of any off aromas or characteristics that would detract from the wines natural flavours and aromas. There are many factors that play an important role in determining a wine’s flavour and aroma--and a wine fault shouldn’t be one of them! This week’s Craft and Cork will teach you where wine faults come from, how to identify them, and most importantly, how to prevent them.
What are Wine Faults?
So, what are wine faults you might ask? A wine fault is a specific chemical compound that can appear at any stage of the winemaking process and are most often a result of poor winemaking practices or incorrect storage conditions. Each chemical compound associated with the wine fault will give off its own unique flavor, aroma, and even appearance in the wine. Wine faults can be grouped into three main categories based primarily on their origin.
1. Oxidation Wine Faults
Oxidation wine faults are a result of exposing the wine to excess amounts of oxygen after the alcoholic fermentation has completed. These include, acetaldehyde (rotten apple), acetic acid (vinegar), and ethyl acetate (nail polish remover). These faults are produced by yeast and bacteria that require
oxygen to survive in the wine. Commercial yeast strains will produce all three of these chemical compounds during the fermentation but at levels that are too low to perceive in the wine.
These faults can be prevented by keeping your carboys topped up with wine or by gassing any headspace in the carboy with nitrogen. Also, keeping the free SO2 levels in the wine between 25-35 ppm post fermentation will help prevent the growth of organisms responsible for these wine faults.
2. Sulphur Wine Faults
This category of wine faults produces some of the most off putting aromas found in wine, but luckily, they are the easiest to prevent. These include, sulphur dioxide (matchsticks), hydrogen sulphide (rotten egg), and mercaptan (onion). Hydrogen sulphide is typically the first of these faults to form in the wine during the primary fermentation. If it is not identified and remedied at this
point it can react with alcohol in the wine forming mercaptan which smells like onion, garlic, or skunk (Phewww!).
Aerating the wine by splashing in the carboy or fermenter is the best way of removing hydrogen sulphide from the wine which will therefore prevent mercaptan from forming. Fermenting your wine at a constant temperature (20-25°C (68-77°F)) will also help prevent these sulphur wine faults from forming.
3. Microbial Wine Faults
Microbial wine faults are caused by microorganisms (yeast & bacteria) that have come in contact with the wine throughout the winemaking process. These faults include geranium, brettanomyces (barnyard), and cork taint (wet basement).
Geranium taint is the result of lactic acid bacteria in the wine metabolizing potassium sorbate added to the wine. Potassium sorbate should not be added to wines that have undergone MLF or have been barrel aged.
The guide below can help you identify an off aroma in your wine in case you are not sure what exactly it is or where it came from. Just remember, proper sanitation and fermentation environment can prevent many of these wine faults from occurring in the first place.
| Fault Category | Wine Symptoms | Chemical | Cause | Solution / How to Avoid It |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oxidation | Vinegar, sharp sour taste | Acetic Acid | Spoilage from yeast or bacteria caused by poor sanitation. Excess oxygen in carboy post fermentation. | Good sanitation practices, keep carboy topped up post fermentation. |
| Nail polish remover, glue, varnish, fake fruit | Ethyl Acetate | Spoilage from yeast or bacteria caused by poor sanitation. Excess oxygen in carboy post fermentation. | Good sanitation practices, keep carboy topped up post fermentation. | |
| Sherry, rotten apple, metallic, nutty | Acetaldehyde | Spoilage from yeast or bacteria caused by poor sanitation. Excess oxygen in carboy post fermentation. | Good sanitation practices, keep carboy topped up post fermentation. | |
| Sulfurous Compounds | Burnt matchsticks, burnt rubber | Sulfur Dioxide | Too much sulfur added to wine or residual sulphite sanitizing solution in carboys or fermenters. | Track amount of sulphite added to wine and always measure sulphite additions. Splash wine vigorously to blow off excess SO2. |
| Rotten egg | Hydrogen Sulphide | Too hot or too cold fermentation temperature, yeast nutrient deficiency, lack of oxygen. | Aerate wine by splashing once identified, avoid temperature extremes. Mix wine with sanitized copper pipe. | |
| Onion, rubber, skunk | Mercaptan | Hydrogen sulphide in the wine reacting with alcohol. | Prevent the occurrence of hydrogen sulphide or aerate wine once first noticed. | |
| Microbial | Rotten geranium | Lactic Acid Bacteria + Potassium Sorbate | Wine that went through malolactic fermentation before being treated with potassium sorbate. | Do not use sorbate if performing MLF. Do not use sorbate if barrel ageing. Filtering wine with carbon filter pads can remove geranium aroma. |
| Band-aids, barnyard, horse stable, manure | Brettanomyces | Wild yeast that is often found in used wine barrels. | Inoculate wine with commercial yeast strains. Maintain adequate SO2 levels in wine post ferment (25–35 ppm SO2). Be cautious when using old wine barrels. | |
| Moldy, musty, wet cardboard, wet basement | TCA (Cork Taint) | Microscopic fungi, in the presence of chlorine and phenolic compounds from cork or oak barrels. | There is no cure to this wine fault. Keep cork supply well away from chlorinated cleaners and sanitizers. Do not rinse wine bottles with Sani-Brew. |